Do you know , i hadn't even wathced the bloke , untill the other forum pointed this similar thing out (lol). I watched the episode where he used this vial e-collar thing on his dog , as a deterrent

don't undersatd why ??. As i said on the forum prevesiously .
My dogs when they hear that noise , you the siis noise a snake makes when his tounge goes in and out (,just stick with me here, rememeber most dogs hearinfg is more advanced than ours) or a air ballon and louder version of this siss, react , they kick up a stink , my dogs also bark at unwelcome vistors in our garden with live in the country and a compost heap makes a nice place for unwelcomed vistors(LOL). So they show a naturall awarness already.
However a rattle snake is the only snake that rattles and perhaps , dogs have become immune to the naturall awarness they should have of the rattler ?? as in modern society there are many thaings that rattle.I would have like them to have used a non rattling variety and then see if the effect could be imulated? (only our of naturall curiousity) does this make sense
However i really could not understand the use of the e-collar

excessive and unessaccarry,??? wouldn't simple adversion techniques have had the same effect manybe not as quickly ?? but i would work better in the long run. You could tell his dog was not happy with the situation as he did a five mile round tour just to avoid the situation , how wicked???.
I have to be honest i do believe in pack therapy though there are some things that our dogs can only ever learn from other dogs ?? hope this isn't a bad thing to say :-).
I have two male leonbergers ,and hoping to add a south african boerboel to my family. totally in love them :-).My boys get on really well with everything and everyone , they are a bit goofy and we love to play allthough can get a little rough (LOL) boys hehehehehehehehehehe. They also love mud , but haven'y found any lately so it must be hot. They are not enjoying all this heat mind and i have to regullay hose them down . My eldest is a gentleman , but stll has an playfull side to him and a puppy brain (tee hee) my youngest is a little teaster always looking for ways to rule to roost (lol) bless him he is the more dominant but is a darling,he is also very playfull. my dogs are my life , i adore every privalaged minute i get to spend with them .
Multing season at the mo , so groomer lady will know what i am up against , need to buy new hoover soon (lol) gets everywhere.
I would just like add regarding qualifications :-).
I know they are usefull and i know people have taken the time out to study very hard , i know alot of excellent friendly and truely excellent qualified behaviorists and trainers ,i also know some that allthough qualified are not as pleasant and quite rubbish. i also undersatnd that there is an increasing number of people out there who claim to be able to do things that they cant and end up destroying and hurting, and causing way more harm .
My hope is wether somone is qualified or not as long as they know what there are doing and always act with a dogs best intention at heart , then they should be welcomed and encouraged.
I am not one of these people , i could go and study , but there is no point , I question idea and ideals , i ask questions and people can find this rather annoying , if the ideas are not though to be correct and i prove different (hopefully you see my point)
i don't belive a book could teach me what i have the privalage and honur of knowing and sharing with my dogs. A book can not teach you how to respond to a given situation
My belief is , if you watch , listen and really take a long thoughfull time over it , our dogs can teach us far more than we even realise , yes my approach is different , but it works.
You have to understand what they are saying , not over analysie or over compensate, then you have to be able to use what they are showing you , and then you watch the responce , its rewarding , but takes a long , long time
Dogs tend to gravatate towards me , it is an honour . It can be frustrating for owners whilst out walking lol ,
Anyway i don't want to sound like i know everthing i am sure there is more for me to learn ,but i prefere dogs to me my teacher , not books . i
I probably sound like a werido now, don't mean to , i am just fortunate enough to be able to help dogs as they respond well to me ?? you need to aske the dogs why not me (LOL)
Hope this post makes sense .